The Best Dog Insurance Plans: Coverage, Costs, and Benefits Compared

Choosing the best dog insurance for your dog can be a daunting task, given the numerous options available in the market. With the cost of veterinary care on the rise, pet insurance has become increasingly popular among dog owners, offering financial protection in case of accidents or illnesses and for routine care.

This article aims to present an unbiased and knowledgeable overview of the top dog insurance providers so you can make an informed decision. In the following sections, we will explore some top-rated pet insurance companies, their key features, and what sets them apart for providing the best protection and peace of mind for dog owners.

Best Dog Insurance

Types of Dog Insurance Plans

It’s essential to understand the factors that contribute to choosing the right plan for your furry friend. As each dog has unique needs and budget considerations, pet owners must weigh factors such as coverage scope, deductible choices, waiting periods, and reimbursement rates, among others.

Each pet insurance provider will have unique nuances to their plans, but there are still three basic plan types that most providers have their own version of. We’ll take a look at the top pet insurance companies in a moemnt, but first, let’s look at these basic plan types.

Accident and Illness Plan

An accident and illness plan is the most comprehensive type of pet insurance, covering both all the worst case scenearios. In this plan, pet owners can expect coverage for:

  • Accidents: Injuries sustained from accidents, such as fractures, bites, lacerations, and ingestion of foreign objects.
  • Illnesses: Sudden and chronic illnesses such as allergies, diabetes, cancer, and heart disease.

These plans usually allow pet owners to choose their deductible, co-insurance, and maximum payout limits. Take some time to review the policy documents to understand the coverage and exclusions.

Accident-Only Plan

An Accident-Only Plan, as the name suggests, provides coverage for accidents but not illnesses. This type of plan is suitable for pet owners who are looking for a more budget-friendly option. Coverage in this plan includes:

  • Accidents: Injuries sustained from accidents, such as fractures, bites, lacerations, and ingestion of foreign objects.

With this type of plan, your pet will be covered when something external happens, such as hit-by-car event or an attack by another animal. But internal emergencies, such as developing cancer or diabetes, are not covered.

Wellness Plan

Wellness plans, also known as preventive care plans, focus on maintaining the overall health and well-being of the pets. These plans provide coverage for routine care and non-emergency services. The scope of coverage in a wellness plan includes:

  • Routine care: Vaccinations, flea/tick prevention, annual check-ups, dental cleanings, and spaying/neutering.

It is important to note that wellness plans are generally not standalone policies and are often offered as an add-on to the main pet insurance policy or alongside an accident and illness plan or an accident-only plan.

Top Dog Insurance Companies

Pets Best

Pets Best offers comprehensive dog insurance plans, with options for both accident and illness coverage. They have flexible annual coverage limits, deductibles, and reimbursement levels, making it easy to customize a plan for your pet’s needs.

Their coverage is straightforward, and they have a quick claims process to get pet owners reimbursed as soon as possible.


Trupanion provides reliable dog insurance with a focus on simple, comprehensive, and customizable coverage.

With a 90% reimbursement rate and no payout limits, Trupanion ensures that pet owners don’t have to compromise on their dog’s health care. They also offer optional coverage for therapy and alternative treatments, as well as dental care.


Embrace Pet Insurance offers two types of plans: accident-only and an accident and illness plan. After a $100 annual deductible, the accident-only plan covers 90% of veterinary expenses.

Embrace stands out for its generous benefits and discounts, including a 10% multi-pet discount and a 24/7 helpline for pet health-related concerns.


ASPCA Pet Insurance is known for its short waiting periods and customizable coverage options. They offer accident-only and accident and illness plans with options for additional wellness coverage.

ASPCA has a variety of annual limits, deductibles, and reimbursement percentages to satisfy the needs of different pet owners.


Nationwide Pet Insurance offers both basic and comprehensive dog insurance plans, with coverage for accidents, illnesses, and chronic conditions.

They also offer reimbursement for alternative and behavioral treatments. Nationwide has a reputation for dependable coverage and a range of flexible options to fit a variety of financial and pet care needs.

Healthy Paws

Healthy Paws is a popular choice for dog insurance because of its straightforward coverage and quick claim processing.

They offer one simple accident and illness plan with no annual or per-incident limits. Healthy Paws has a customer-friendly approach, with unlimited payout options and annual deductible choices.


Figo Pet Insurance is known for its highly customizable coverage options and 100% reimbursement rate, making it a great choice for pet owners who want maximum control over their dog’s insurance.

They offer flexible deductibles and annual limits, as well as additional coverage for vet exam fees and alternative therapies. Figo’s easy-to-use app makes managing your dog’s coverage and claims simple and convenient.

Understanding Restrictions and Exclusions

Pre-Existing Conditions

Pre-existing conditions are medical issues your dog had before the start of the insurance policy. Pet insurance companies typically don’t cover these conditions to prevent fraud and maintain affordability.

It’s crucial to understand your chosen insurer’s definition of pre-existing conditions, as some companies may not include conditions that have been cured or have had no symptoms for a specified time period.

Hereditary Conditions

Hereditary conditions are health issues passed down through a dog’s genes. Examples include hip dysplasia, heart disease, and certain types of cancer.

Some pet insurance policies may exclude hereditary conditions, especially for breeds known to have specific genetic health problems. However, other policies may offer coverage for hereditary conditions, usually at an additional cost or with a specific cap on reimbursement.

Congenital Conditions

Congenital conditions are present at birth but not always hereditary. These can include heart defects, cleft palate, or limb deformities.

While some pet insurance policies exclude congenital conditions altogether, others may cover them with certain limitations on coverage amounts or only if they manifest and are diagnosed after a specified waiting period.

Hip Dysplasia Exam

Waiting Periods

A waiting period is a set time frame during which new insurance policyholders are not eligible for coverage or reimbursement for certain conditions or events.

The waiting period varies depending on the insurer and type of coverage. Accidents may have a waiting period as short as a few days, while illnesses or other conditions could have a longer waiting period, sometimes up to six months. Check your policy’s fine print to determine the exact waiting periods that apply to your specific plan.

In summary, it’s essential to read and understand the restrictions and exclusions outlined in your pet insurance policy to avoid surprises when submitting a claim. Pre-existing, hereditary, and congenital conditions can impact coverage availability, and waiting periods can delay when you’re eligible for reimbursement.

Cost of Dog Insurance


The cost of dog insurance can vary significantly based on factors such as breed, age, location, and coverage options. On average, the monthly premium for dog insurance is $42 across the top pet insurance companies.

However, for the same pet, location, and insurance plan, quotes can vary by more than $65 across companies. If you live in an area with expensive veterinary costs or have an injury-prone dog, you can expect your monthly rate to be closer to $90 than $25.

Reimbursement Rates

Reimbursement rates affect the amount you receive from the pet insurance company when you make a claim. Most insurance providers offer a range of reimbursement choices, such as 70%, 80%, or 90%.

Piggy Bank

Higher reimbursement rates may result in higher premiums, but they can also significantly reduce your out-of-pocket expenses when it comes to costly medical treatments.

Annual Limits

Annual limits are another important factor to consider when comparing dog insurance policies. These limits represent the maximum amount an insurance company will pay for covered veterinary expenses within a policy year.

Many pet insurance plans offer a range of annual coverage limits, from $5,000 to unlimited. Choosing a higher annual limit will likely increase your premiums but can provide financial protection in case of a major illness or accident.

Frequently Asked Questions

How do I choose the best pet insurance?

When choosing the best pet insurance for your dog, consider factors such as the range of coverage options, policy features, and the reputation of the insurance provider.

How much should you spend on pet insurance for your dog?

The cost of pet insurance for your dog will vary depending on factors such as breed, age, location, and coverage level. Monthly premiums can range from $10 to over $100. It’s essential to consider your dog’s specific needs and budget when determining how much to spend on pet insurance.

Is pet insurance worth it?

Whether pet insurance is worth it depends on your dog’s health, your financial situation, and your peace of mind.

Happy Dog

Pet insurance can help cover unexpected costs from accidents, illnesses, and chronic conditions, potentially saving pet owners thousands of dollars. Consider your pet’s medical history and your ability to afford out-of-pocket expenses when deciding if pet insurance is right for you.

What pet insurance can you use right away?

Some pet insurance providers offer policies with minimal or no waiting periods, allowing you to use the coverage immediately after enrollment.

However, keep in mind that pre-existing conditions are often excluded from coverage, and some insurers may still require waiting periods for specific illnesses or accidents. Be sure to read the policy terms and conditions to understand when your coverage begins.

Wrapping up the Best Dog Insurance

By considering a variety of pet insurance options, you can find a suitable plan to ensure your furbaby receives the best possible care with the least amount of financial strain for you. Save money on your dog’s dental work by checking out this post on the Importance of Dog Dental Cleaning for Oral Health.

Leave a Comment